How Does Anne Shirley Challenge Authority
At eleven years old, Anne Shirley in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery and Harry Potter in Harry Potter and Philosopher Stone by J. K. Rowling are orphans who seek for acceptance in their respective communities of Green Gables and Hogwarts. As orphans, Anne Shirley and Harry Potter enter their communities as outsiders who struggle to understand their position. However, Anne and Harry respond differently to their new community as they both challenge authority with their limited amount of power. When Anne arrives at Green Gables, she comes as a surprise to Matthew and Marilla Cuthbert, brother and sister, who expected a boy to help with their home, instead were given a girl. Anne's arrival challenges the community and the authorities with her imagination and actions that she struggles to conform because no one takes her seriously. Yet, Harry Potter enters Hogwarts with praise among the students and teachers; except, he struggles to understand his ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...Anne challenges Marilla's rules when she questions Marilla against her upbringing in regard to saying her prayers when Marilla tells Anne, "You must say your prayers while you are under my roof" (Montgomery 59). Thus, Anne talks back when she questions whether she prays the right way. As a result, Anne challenges Marilla with her curiosity because she wants to prove she is able to conform to her duties. Furthermore, she is constantly given duties to perform, which she cannot keep up. The pressure to conform challenges Anne to challenge Marilla against her behaviour, to prove she is part of the community. However, Joe Sutliff Sanders argues that Marilla is partially to blame because she pushes Anne to challenge her curiosity in order to make the right choices (89). Yet, Anne is unable to fully abide to her needs unless she abides to others. For that reason, Anne lies to please Marilla against the missing
... Get more on HelpWriting.net ...
No comments:
Post a Comment