City Of Glass Graphic Book Analysis

City Of Glass Graphic Book Analysis

City of Glass the novel written by Paul Auster and its comic adaptation by Paul Karasik and David Mazzucchelli have ways that they are the same and ways they are different. The part of both books I am going to focus on is from the time the main character, William Wilson a.k.a Quinn, goes to the train station to keep an eye on the elderly Peter Stillman on behalf of Virginia Stillman to the time where Quinn loses sight of Peter Stillman. There are several similarities as well as differences that I saw in this interval of time. Ultimately, the graphic novel does stand alone as a story; however, as it routinely leaves out content as well as making other changes, it makes an effect on the readers that is different than the effect the original ... Show more content on Helpwriting.net ...The thing to note in both of these situations is that the graphic novel just makes implications, while the original novel gives more explanations. This is because the essence of a novel is different than the essence of a graphic novel. So far, and as readers will see later, the original City of Glass novel is more detailed, but detail is not always needed. The problem arises when a story leaves out something that is essential to understanding what is going on. Before I go into how the graphic novel leaves out detail, I want to talk about a few more instances where the novel and the graphic novel are roughly equal in their storytelling so that when I describe the graphic novel's flaws, it will be easier to understand. There are a few times when this happens: when Quinn is hesitant as to which Stillman to follow, and when Quinn follows the Stillman to the hotel. These occurrences that happen both in the novel and graphic novel are conveyed in a satisfactory manner. The first big difference we see is implied. The original novel describes that Quinn saw two elderly Stillmans, one dressed better and one dressed worse. However, the narration is not specific enough. It does not say anything about the two Stillmans supposedly having the same eye color, hair color, or facial features. Also, anything described by the narration could be faulty. In the

... Get more on HelpWriting.net ...